Rachel's ears perked as she heard a voice she vaguely recognized before looking the person in the face. Of course it was someone who would critique her choices. "Well, it's a good thing I didn't ask your opinion then, isn't it?" she replied, crossing her arms.

She eyed him carefully, before recognition fully hit. "Oh my God, I went to school with you didn't I?" she asked before answering it herself "You're the only real competition I had in glee club and I'm using that term loosely. What an incredibly small world." she mumbled the last bit of her sentence "You're looking...good."